Where to Sell Old Electronics for Cash on Long Island
Sell Your Gadgets has 3 walk-in stores on Long Island (East Meadow, Huntington, and Islip Terrace) that buy old phones, laptops, tablets, game consoles, and other electronics, working or broken, and pay cash the same day after an in-person inspection. Other Long Island options include PayMore stores, ecoATM kiosks for phones, and Facebook Marketplace.
Updated November 4, 2026. Written by Sell Your Gadgets. Store counts update automatically from our store records.
Your options, compared
Based on each company's publicly available information. We don't list prices because offers depend on the exact device and its condition.
1. Sell Your Gadgets
Walk-in buyback stores (plus free mail-in)
- How you get paid:
- Cash on the spot, the same day, after a buyer inspects the item in front of you. Zelle or check at many stores.
- Best for:
- Same-day cash in Nassau and Suffolk County, for working or broken electronics.
- Watch out for:
- Offers are made in person, not from an online price list. Bring a photo ID and sign out of iCloud, Google, or Samsung first.
2. PayMore
Walk-in buyback stores (franchise)
- How you get paid:
- Paid in store after an in-person evaluation.
- Best for:
- Shoppers who have a PayMore location nearby.
- Watch out for:
- Store hours and what each location buys vary, so call ahead.
3. ecoATM
Self-serve kiosks in grocery stores, Walmarts, and malls
- How you get paid:
- Cash from the kiosk if you accept its offer.
- Best for:
- A quick phone sale when a kiosk is closer than a store.
- Watch out for:
- Mostly phones, tablets, and smartwatches. A machine grades the device, so there is no one to explain the offer. Photo ID required.
4. Pawn shops
Walk-in lenders that also buy
- How you get paid:
- Cash, either as a loan against the item or an outright purchase.
- Best for:
- Short-term loans when you want the item back.
- Watch out for:
- Loans carry interest and deadlines. Many pawn shops buy electronics only as collateral.
5. Facebook Marketplace / Craigslist
Local person-to-person listings
- How you get paid:
- Cash or app payment from a stranger when you meet.
- Best for:
- Patient sellers comfortable meeting buyers.
- Watch out for:
- No-shows, haggling, and scam risk. Meet in a public place and never ship before you are paid.
Sell Your Gadgets stores on Long Island
- Sell Your Gadgets East Meadow, NY477 Newbridge Rd, East Meadow, NY 11554(516) 765-3511
- Sell Your Gadgets Huntington, NY1937 New York Ave, Huntington, NY 11746(631) 223-3210
- Sell Your Gadgets Islip Terrace, NY34 Lowell Ave, Islip Terrace, NY 11752(631) 446-1050
Before you sell anywhere
- Get quotes on the same day. Resale prices move with new releases and demand.
- Compare what you actually take home: cash versus store credit, minus shipping or fees.
- Describe condition honestly, so the offers you compare are real.
- Back up your data, then sign out of iCloud / Find My, Google, or Samsung before you sell anywhere.
Common questions
Where can I sell my old electronics on Long Island?+
At any Sell Your Gadgets store on Long Island. Walk in with the item and a photo ID, get an offer, and get paid the same day if you accept.
Do you buy broken electronics on Long Island?+
Yes. Cracked, water-damaged, and non-working devices are accepted for a lower offer.
Have a different question? Browse 160+ answers in our full FAQ
Want a real offer to compare?
Get a free, no-obligation quote and same-day cash at your nearest store.
Get a free quote